HOME    CONTACT US    MESSAGE BOARD

The Legend of Spooky Hollow

 

Location:   Eureka Center, Polk County, Wisconsin

 

The Reputed History:  

About 1900, between Cushing and St. Croix Falls, a small hamlet, later known as Eureka Center, developed.  This community was centered around a creamery.  The first settler was Matt Young.  The town was then known as "Yellow Dog Town."

The Witch

About one half mile east of this community there was a neighborhood known as "Spooky Hollow."  Many strange stories have been told about this community.  At that time there lived an elderly lady known to people in the surrounding territory as a witch, and whom many believed caused many mysteries.  She possessed what was known to many as the "Little Black Book."  This book was burned seven times; but after each burning, it turned up along the clock on the shelf in her home the next morning.

There was an old bachelor who also lived in Spooky Hollow.  He was known to everyone as "Mule Pete."  Mule Pete used to buy cookies at the store to share with his little dog.  He was an ardent believer in the little black book.  Many people living in and around Eureka Center are still haunted by these very uncanny tales and are to this day afraid to travel after dark on this road, because of the superstitions about the little black book.  If anyone were to read the book, they were sure to die.

Many say this lady was not a witch; and others say she was as she had some very supernatural powers.  There is a story about a man who bought cattle.  He was talking to the supposed "witch" one day and asking her about her powers in a teasing manner.  As he left, he told her he was going to buy cattle the next morning.  She told him he wouldn't get very far.  This man lived on what is now the Orvin Johnson place.  He got as far as the next place that morning, where Bobby Swanson lives now, when his horse became suddenly lame, and he had to return home.  He was sure a hex had been put on him.

Another time a man whom the witch didn't like was putting up a load of hay.  He had the wagon all loaded when it very mysteriously tipped over, and he had to reload all the hay.  He was sure he was hexed.

Strange Happenings

There are other stories, telling of very strange noises as you come through the hollow.  If you came through there after midnight with a horse and buggy, you could almost be sure that the chains would drop off from the horses and the horses would tear off down the road, leaving the buggy behind.  It was up to the driver then to catch and hook up the horses again before going on.

The Phantom White Steed and Rider

There is a story that many years ago a man who lived near Twin Lake always went into town early every morning.  Late in the evening he used to come riding home on his white steed.  He did the very same thing for many years.  When this man passed away, they had a small funeral for him.  Because he lived alone, a neighbor man was hired to close up his house and store his belongings.  It was dark before he had finished the job; and as he was leaving, he heard a strange noise.  There, charging down the road towards him was a phantom white steed with the ghost of the dead man riding in the saddle.  The man went home quickly.  Many people have seen the phantom white steed and the dead man rider come down the road and then disappear in a cloud of dust.

Should you be in Spooky Hollow some time after midnight and see this apparition, you will know it is the ghost rider on his nightly ride.

 

Polk County Historical Society
PO Box 41
Balsam Lake, WI 54810-0041
Phone: 715-268-8375

The fully restored Baker Building-Headquarters of the St. Croix Falls Historical Society

Polk County Historical Society (NW)


St. Croix Falls Chapter
P.O. Box 281
St. Croix Falls, WI, 54024
Phone: (715) 483-3580 or (715) 483-3066
Web site: www.stcroixfallschamber.com

scf public library

The library is located in scenic downtown St. Croix Falls, just across from the Overlook Deck. The library entrance is on the south side of the Festival Theater Auditorium.

St. Croix Falls Library
210 N. Washington St.
St. Croix Falls, WI 54024
(715) 483-1777

Hours
Sunday: Closed
Monday: 10-8
Tuesday: 10-6
Wednesday: 10-8
Thursday: 10-6
Friday: 10-6
Saturday: 9-12

DAVIDSON'S ISLAND CEMETERY


Designed by Terry Fisk
Copyright © Unexplained Research. All rights reserved.
Revised: September 28, 2004

Designed by Terry Fisk
Copyright © Unexplained Research. All rights reserved.
Revised: September 28, 2004